Guide · Wheelers Hill homes
Heat Pump or Electric Storage Hot Water?
When the old cylinder gives out, most Wheelers Hill households end up choosing between a heat pump and a new electric storage tank. Here is how they compare.
How each one heats water
An electric storage cylinder uses an element, much like a kettle, to heat water in an insulated tank. A heat pump uses a fan and compressor to pull warmth from the surrounding air into the water, using a fraction of the electricity for the same amount of hot water.
Running costs
A heat pump typically uses far less electricity than a standard electric cylinder. If you have rooftop solar, a heat pump timed to run in the middle of the day can use mostly your own power. An electric cylinder on an off-peak tariff is cheaper to run than one on a general tariff, but still uses more energy than a heat pump.
Upfront considerations
A heat pump usually costs more to buy and install than a like-for-like electric tank, but government incentives have often been available. We do not quote prices on the website because every home is different; we give you a firm quote after seeing the site.
Placement and noise
Heat pumps need airflow and make a low hum, similar to an air conditioner. Keep them away from bedroom windows and out of enclosed spaces. Electric tanks are silent and can go almost anywhere, including inside.
Recovery
Electric elements reheat a tank faster than many heat pumps. For big families with several showers in a row, tank size matters with either system.
Which suits you
- Choose a heat pump if you want lower running costs, have space outside and especially if you have solar panels
- Choose electric storage if space or noise rules out a heat pump, or for a simple like-for-like swap
Need advice?
Ring 03 9088 4761 and we will help you choose.
Maintenance
Both systems need the relief valve eased regularly and replaced periodically.
Quotes and bookings
Tell us what is going on
Send a few details and a licensed Wheelers Hill plumber will call you back. If water is escaping right now, ring 03 9088 4761 instead.
We do not list prices online. We inspect, explain and agree the cost with you before any work begins.
Reading list
More guides
Wheelers Hill Plumbing